Mareh Makom · Power ·

Power: When the invisible gaze turns us into our own guards

What happens when the fear of the gaze becomes stronger than the gaze itself?

Source: Big Brother sees all: When fear becomes an instinct

"There was no way to know if you were being watched at any given moment... You had to live – and so indeed you lived, out of a habit that became an instinct – under the assumption that every sound you made was heard, and every movement of yours was examined."

(George Orwell, 1984)

Explanation: Internalizing the gaze: How people become their own prison guards

Orwell describes in his book a dystopian reality in which the regime, known as "Big Brother," sees all. The psychological principle at work here is what philosophers call "internalizing the gaze": since a person never knows exactly when the camera is operating, they are forced to behave as if they are being watched at any given moment. This produces the ultimate effect of power—a person becomes their own prison guard. They fall in line and obey norms not because a police officer is standing beside them, but out of constant fear and the knowledge that they are completely transparent.

Perspective: Voluntary surveillance: When we choose to be transparent

Orwell feared a regime that would force surveillance upon us, but it was hard to imagine that we would gladly volunteer for it. Today, social networks and databases are the modern "Big Brother." We behave in a certain way in front of the cameras—extreme or moderate, conservative or progressive—before a cheering crowd. Power today is not in the hands of those holding weapons, but in the hands of those holding the databases. Google and Facebook don't need to resort to violence; the mere knowledge that they know everything about us is enough to shape our consciousness and behavior.

Going Deeper: Surveillance capitalism: The power of the one who knows

Shoshana Zuboff, in her book The Age of Surveillance Capitalism, argues that this new economic power is based on predicting human behavior. The tech giants don't just watch us; they use data to alter our behavior in real time. She calls this phenomenon "surveillance capitalism"—a quiet, invisible power, and therefore far more dangerous than any overt dictatorship of the twentieth century.

Culture: Free fall: When ratings become reality

In "Nosedive," the season three premiere of Black Mirror, we see a world where everyone receives a star rating from the people around them for every single interaction. People with high ratings receive perks, while those with low ratings are ostracized. The result is a society of anxious, fake people smiling through gritted teeth, trapped in a prison of "niceness" for fear of losing their status. It is the ultimate digital, intelligent version of "internalizing the gaze."