Mareh Makom · Anger ·

Anger: When the evil inclination becomes an inner idol

What is the connection between breaking a plate and idol worship?

Source: Anger as idol worship: The manifestation of the evil inclination

"One who tears his clothes in his anger, and one who breaks his vessels in his anger, and one who scatters his money in his anger, should be in your eyes like an idol worshiper... What is the scripture [what is the verse]? 'There shall be no strange god within you, and you shall not bow down to an alien god' (Psalms 81:10). What is the strange god that is within a person's body? You must say: it is the evil inclination."

(Babylonian Talmud, Tractate Shabbat, 105b)

Explanation: The center of the world: A theology of the ego

The Sages use harsh language. They compare someone who breaks dishes or tears clothes out of fury ("in his anger") to an idol worshiper, the gravest sin in the Bible. The logic is theological, rooted in the verse from Psalms: "There shall be no strange god within you." The Talmud asks: What god is found inside the body rather than outside it? The answer is the evil inclination (the ego/anger). A person of faith knows that everything comes from God; if you get angry when something doesn't go your way, you are declaring: "I am the one who decides." In that moment, you have crowned your own inner anger as a god.

Perspective: Humility as a remedy: Beyond anger management

Even detached from a religious context, the link between anger and narcissism is exact. Anger almost always stems from a gap between our expectations and reality. We get angry because "they didn't respect us," because "we deserve better." The angry person is preoccupied entirely with themselves and the slight to their dignity. The remedy for anger, according to this view, is not "anger management" but humility. Recognizing that we are not the center of the world is the finest antidote to fits of rage.

Going Deeper: Possessed by a dybbuk: When the soul is replaced by rage

The Zohar (parashat Tetzaveh, the weekly Torah portion) takes this idea to a mystical extreme, arguing that anger is an act of "soul exchange." When a person rages ("tears his soul in his anger"), he drives his divine soul out, creating a vacuum entered by an "alien god" (the sitra achra, the kabbalistic "other side" of impurity). The angry person is, quite literally, possessed by a dybbuk (a possessing spirit). This is a frightening yet accurate explanation for what people are capable of when they "see red"—violence completely alien to their ordinary character. Pictured here is Hanna Rovina in S. An-sky's famous play The Dybbuk: an angry, wounded soul entering another body and turning into rage.

Culture: Zidane's headbutt: An Achilles moment on the pitch

The 2006 World Cup final. Zinedine Zidane, one of the greatest soccer players in history, is playing his final match. France is counting on him. But then, in response to a verbal taunt and provocation from an Italian player, Zidane turns around and headbutts him forcefully in the chest. He is sent off with a red card, walks off the field in disgrace, and France loses the trophy. It is a classic Achilles moment: the hero chooses the immediate satisfaction of revenge over the collective good (the national team), paying for it with his career and his legacy.